When it comes to cleaners and disinfectants, one common point of contention is whether Pine SOL and Pine Glo are interchangeable. They have similar names, advertise a pine fragrance, and serve similar functions. The price is the most obvious distinction.
While the former is a worthwhile cleaning product investment, the latter is quite cost-effective. So, is there a clear advantage to using Pine SOL or a disadvantage to using Pine Glo?
Pine Glo vs. Pine-Sol: Comparison
| Comparison Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Product Property | Pine Glo offers a range of cleaning products, while Pine-Sol, with a focus on multi-surface cleaners, provides disinfectant in its Original cleaner. |
| Fragrance | Pine-Sol maintains a unique and longer-lasting scent with pine oil, unlike Pine Glo, which relies on artificial chemicals, resulting in a generic and short-lived fragrance. |
| Ingredients | Both Pine Glo and Pine-Sol, rated poorly by the Environmental Work Group, use different active ingredients with environmental and health concerns. |
| Uses | Pine Glo is EPA-registered for kitchens and bathrooms, functioning as a disinfectant, while Pine-Sol is a versatile, all-purpose cleaner. |
| Dilution | The price similarity arises from Pine SOL's dilution option for lighter use, unlike Pine Glo, which loses effectiveness when diluted. |
| Health Effects | Modern regulations have made both Pine Glo and Pine SOL less dangerous, but they can still cause discomfort, with Pine Glo being slightly more aggressive in closed spaces. |
Product Property
Pine Glo has a broader selection of cleaning products than Pine-Sol. The Antibacterial & Disinfectant Cleaner is Pine Glo’s main product. They do, however, provide a diverse range of cleaning products.
All of these products are manufactured by Pine Glo, but some are marketed under sub-brands such as Septix, Glass Glo, Green Power, and Renew.
Pine-Sol’s product line is more focused. While the Original Multi-Surface Cleaner (pine-scented) is the brand’s most well-known product, it also produces multi-surface cleaners in other scents, a floor cleaner, and a wood polish.
While all Pine-Sol products leave your home smelling fresh and clean, only the Original pine-scented cleaner is a disinfectant.
Fragrance
This is the first indication that the two are not identical. Even though real pine oil is no longer a major constituent of Pine SOL, it is still used to give the product its distinct aroma. As a result, the scent is more pleasant and lasts longer. It also does not deteriorate over time. It’s also not overpowering.
Does Pine Glo have pine oil? Pine Glo makes no use of pine oil. Its fragrance is provided by synthetic chemicals. While they attempt to make it smell like pine, the fragrance comes across as cheap imitation.
It is rather generic in nature, and the fragrance does not last very long. When used in close quarters, this fragrance can also degrade quite quickly.
Ingredients
The ingredients are one of the most noticeable differences between Pine-Sol and Pine Glo.
Pine Glo is not a “green” cleaning product. It’s a potent formula that contains harsh ingredients. Its disinfectant cleaners contain various formulations of ammonium chloride, which acts as a disinfectant.
Pine Glo contains chelating agent Tetrasodium ethylenediamine tetraacetate, surfactant Ethoxylated C9-11 Alcohols, and detergent Sodium metasilicate pentahydrate. These ingredients aid in the breakdown and removal of grease and grime.
Many people associate Pine-Sol with pine oil because it was the main ingredient when the product was invented in 1929 and grew in popularity over the next several decades.
However, pine oil is no longer used in modern formulations. Pine-Sol Original, on the other hand, contains glycolic acid, an organic acid capable of removing dirt, grease, and tough messes such as soap scum and hard water stains.
Uses
Pine Glo liquid multi-surface cleaners are ideal for use in kitchens and bathrooms, where germs thrive. Pine Glo is a registered disinfectant according to the EPA. As a result, wiping your counter with it removes grime and potentially harmful germs.
Pine-Sol is most famous for its liquid disinfectant cleaner. It is ideal for removing stubborn stains, soap scum, and hard water deposits. However, its applications are not limited to simple cleaning.
Dilution
This best explains why the prices of these two products are the same. While Pine SOL can be diluted for lighter applications, Pine Glo must always be used as is. Pine Glo loses a significant portion of its cleaning and disinfecting abilities when diluted, whereas Pine SOL does not.
Health effects
In this regard, they are similar. Cleaning products are no longer as dangerous as they once were due to modern regulations governing them. They can, however, cause some discomfort.
Both can cause breathing problems if used in a confined space, with Pine Glo being slightly more aggressive. The same can be said for their proclivity to aggravate allergies. When using Pine Glo, some people experience skin irritation. In this case, Pine SOL is the better of two bad options.
FAQ’s
Q: What Surfaces Can Pine Glo And Pine-Sol Be Used On?
A: Both products are safe to use on non-porous, hard surfaces. Pine-Sol is also non-hazardous to finished hardwood, cement, carpet, or glass. It is safe on some painted surfaces, but always test in a small area first before applying it widely.
Q: Is Bleach Present In Pine Glo Or Pine-Sol?
A: Pine Glo and Pine-Sol multi-surface cleaners do not contain bleach. Some Pine Glo products, such as the drain opener, do, however, contain sodium hypochlorite (bleach).
Q: Is It Okay To Combine Pine Glo And Pine-Sol With Bleach?
A: Never combine Pine Glo or Pine-Sol with bleach or other cleaning products or chemicals. When they are combined, hazardous gasses may be released.
Q: Is Ammonia Present In Pine Glo And Pine-Sol?
A: Pine-Sol cleaners are ammonia-free, but Pine Glo contains ammonia. Pine Glo contains ammonium chloride as one of its main ingredients.
Q: Do Pine Glo And Pine-Sol Produce A Lot Of Fumes?
A: Pine Glo and Pine-Sol, like many other chemical cleaners, emit fumes when used. Although not particularly potent, they may irritate your lungs if inhaled repeatedly. When using either product, make sure the room is well-ventilated by opening a window.
Q: Is Pine Glo And Pine-Sol Harmful To Your Health?
A: The Environmental Working Group has classified the ingredients in both cleaners as potentially hazardous. When using Pine Glo or Pine-Sol, protect your skin and eyes, keep the room well ventilated, and keep them out of the reach of children and pets.
Q: Pine Sol Vs Pine Gel
Pine sol is a classic liquid pine cleaner ideal for mopping and heavy duty cleaning. Pine gel thick formula clings to vertical surfaces better when cleaning countertops, walls, and appliances by hand. Both provide refreshing pine scent and effective grease-cutting action at an affordable price.
Conclusion
Choosing the right cleaning products may not appear to be a big deal at first, but it can have a significant impact in terms of both money and effort. Pine Glo is designed specifically for those on a tight budget.
It has flaws but it still works. However, if you can obtain Pine SOL, do so because the additional benefits outweigh the premium price.
More On Topic:
