When searching for new cookware, two brands consistently rise to the top – HexClad and Caraway. Both offer durable, non-toxic cookware made from stainless steel, but they have some notable differences.
As I compared hexclad pans vs caraway in my own search, a few key factors emerged that helped me decide which was best for my needs.
Which is Better Hexclad or Caraway: Checkout With The Features
Construction and Materials
The most obvious difference between HexClad and Caraway cookware is the construction and materials used.
HexClad
HexClad uses a unique hybrid triple-layer metal composition:
- The interior cooking surface uses 18/10 stainless steel. This provides excellent food release properties while being safe for contact with food.
- The core of every HexClad pan is pure aluminum, which conducts heat quickly and evenly across the base and up sides. This ensures efficient, uniform heating.
- The exterior uses a proprietary 18/10 stainless steel with a striking hexagonal pattern engraved throughout. HexClad developed this exterior layer to optimize durability, corrosion-resistance and further non-stick release of foods during cooking and plating.
Caraway
In contrast to the high tech Hybrid Hex core, Caraway cookware uses a more classic tri-ply clad construction:
- The interior cooking surface uses commercial grade 18/10 stainless steel like HexClad. The steel is non-reactive, protecting food flavors and quality.
- The heat conducting core layer is thick aluminum, nearly 4mm thick extending up the sides. This allows for rapid heat conduction.
- Instead of a hexagonal exterior, Caraway uses brushed stainless steel for the same classic style inside and out. The external layer is magnetized for induction cooktop compatibility.
Non-Stick Properties
Where Caraway differs is its patented ceramic non-stick coating called Ceramic PLUS:
- The PTFE-free, PFOA-free ceramic coating is applied to the stainless interior for an almost indestructible slick surface.
- This gives Caraway non-stick abilities comparable to the food release properties HexClad achieves from its specialized exterior layering.
- Both brands offer commercial-grade, quick-heating aluminum cores locked between durable steel. HexClad stands apart with patented hexagonal layers claiming to outperform classic triply. But Caraway matches slick non-stick performance using ceramic coatings rather than exotic alloys.
Cooking Ability
When comparing cooking ability, hexclad seems to have a slight edge. The unique hexagonal layer and tri-ply metals help distribute heat quickly and evenly. Food release is effortless, rivaling traditional non-stick pans.
The mix of materials puts hexclad pans a step above Caraway in versatility – you can use them on induction cooktops or for high-heat searing.
That said, Caraway is no slouch. The non-stick ceramic coating provides an impressive food release with little to no oil needed. And the aluminum core similarly allows for fast, even heating. Just avoid using Caraway at extremely high direct heats, and be diligent about not overheating empty pans.
So HexClad would be my top choice for high-heat tasks like stir frying or searing meat. But for everyday cooking at low or medium heat, Caraway cookware works beautifully.
Handles and Lids
The handles and lids on both HexClad and Caraway cookware lines aim for both form and function. Here’s a deeper look at how they compare:
Handles
- HexClad uses metal handles riveted to the body of each pan. They have a rounded contour shape intended for an easy and secure grip, comparable to what you find on traditional cast iron pans.
- Caraway handles have a sleek, modern tapered silhouette. They extend from the pan rim for leverage in lifting, curving subtly for ergonomic comfort. The slender handle design complements the pan exterior.
In terms of materials and heat safety:
- HexClad handles are stainless steel, which allows them to match the tri-ply construction. They stay relatively cool on the stovetop thanks to the riveted design avoiding direct contact heat conduction.
- Caraway boasts solid stainless steel handles designed to resist heating up to 500°F. So, you can safely grasp and maneuver the cookware directly from a hot oven.
Lids
Both brands designer cookware sets use vented tempered glass lids:
- The lids allow easy food monitoring without losing heat or moisture. The vents let steam escape to prevent boiling over or lids rattling from steam pressure.
- HexClad lids have a stainless steel rim with a subtle HexClad logo etched into the glass. Caraway lids are entirely glass for a seamless modern look.
- HexClad lids have large external knobs for easy gripping and lifting. Caraway lids feature smaller inlaid knobs that continue the smooth aesthetic.
In terms of performance, HexClad edges out Caraway:
- HexClad lids are oven safe up to 500°F to use when roasting or baking.
- Caraway lids should not go in the oven over 350°F, restricting versatility. The glass is more vulnerable to cracking or shattering under broiling temperatures.
- So while Caraway offers sleeker styling in line with contemporary kitchen design, HexClad delivers better durability and functionality. Caraway focuses more on aesthetic, while HexClad assures sturdy performance to match technique-driven cooking.
Oven Safety
Want to start a dish on the stovetop then finish cooking it in the oven? This convenience factor differs between the two brands:
- HexClad cookware is entirely oven and broiler safe up to 500°F. The stainless steel layers allow you to freely move the pans between stovetop and oven.
- Caraway pans have oven-safe bodies but glass lids. This limits any pans with lids to oven temperatures of 350°F or below. The lids can crack under extreme heat.
So HexClad is the better choice if you plan to regularly use pans for high temp roasting, broiling or baking in the oven. Caraway pans still offer some oven versatility though as long as you remove lids first.
Cleaning and Maintenance
When it comes to cleaning cookware, Caraway wins for ease thanks to the durable non-stick ceramic coating:
- Food residue wipes away cleanly from Caraway pans with minimal effort, often requiring just a soft sponge or cloth. The slick coating prevents sticking or stubborn baked-on messes.
- HexClad must be hand washed and requires a bit more scrubbing with a gentle abrasive pad if any food sticks after cooking. You’ll need to use a bit of elbow grease for anything stuck to the stainless steel surface.
Over time through continuous use, there will be some differences in longevity:
- The patented hexagonal layer on HexClad makes it metal utensil safe without damaging the durable exterior surface. It can withstand plenty of long term use and scrubbing.
- Caraway’s ceramic non-stick surface will gradually wear away over a year or two of heavy cooking, especially if using harsh abrasive cleaners or utensils regularly.
- The coating may eventually lose its effectiveness.
Proper maintenance plays a key role as well:
- For HexClad, avoid abrasive cleaners or steel wool that could scratch the surfaces. Stick to soft sponges and gentle dish soap instead. Some recommend re-seasoning the pans every few months to revive slickness.
- For Caraway, gentle hand washing maintains the integrity of the coating for longer effectiveness. You want to baby these pans more than be aggressive in scrubbing away stuck bits which can remove non-stick layers faster.
- So choose Caraway if quick and easy cleanup is most important between uses. But opt for HexClad if longevity and long-term value appeal for years of cooking down the road.
- Proper and regular maintenance makes a big difference for either to stay looking and cooking like new! Evaluate your own care tendencies before deciding which is a better matchup.
Cost Comparison
Both brands fall into the premium cookware category – with premium prices to match! Here is how they generally compare:
- A 10-12 piece set from HexClad costs $1000-1300.
- Caraway 10-piece sets runs $545-595 depending on current discounts or sales.
HexClad commands a significantly higher price for its patented technology and tri-ply construction. Meanwhile, Caraway tries to balance high performance with a (relatively) more budget-friendly price point. You can also purchase individual pieces or smaller sets from each brand for a lower upfront investment.
The Bottom Line
So which brand reigns supreme – HexClad or Caraway? While HexClad edges out in a few performance metrics like heat distribution and oven safety, you really cannot go wrong with either brand. Both offer durable, non-toxic cookware made to last for years with the right care.
FAQ
1. What Type Of Cookware Are Hexclad And Caraway?
Both HexClad and Caraway are considered premium or professional-grade cookware. They use commercial quality stainless steel paired with heat conducting aluminum and feature proprietary tech for non-stick abilities.
HexClad uses a patented hexagonal layered exterior while Caraway relies on a PFOA-free ceramic interior coating.
2. How Do Hexclad And Caraway Handle Heating?
HexClad and Caraway both heat quickly and evenly thanks to their aluminum cores. HexClad’s unique triple layered construction gives it an edge for versatile high heat searing and stability. But Caraway is nearly as good for everyday cooking tasks.
3. Is Caraway Cookware Oven Safe?
Caraway’s cookware bodies are oven safe up to 500°F but the lids have a lower threshold around 350°F before risking cracks from the intense dry heat. For roasting or baking where cookware goes directly in a hot oven, HexClad is the safer choice.
4. Does Hexclad Require Seasoning Like Cast Iron?
HexClad doesn’t require seasoning out of the box, unlike cast iron. But occasionally re-seasoning with oil can help revive the natural slickness and protection of the exterior hexagonal later over years of heavy use.
5. Which Cookware Is Easier To Clean?
Caraway’s PFOA-free ceramic non-stick coated interiors mean most food residue and sauces wipe away without any effort or soaking needed. HexClad relies solely on the properties of stainless steel so stuck bits require a bit more scrubbing to clean
It comes down to deciding what specific features or benefits hold the greatest importance for your needs in the kitchen. Do you want striking style and high performance to splurge on luxury HexClad? Or does reliable quality for hundreds less fit your budget better via Caraway?
Evaluate the pros, cons and pricing to determine what best suits your cooking lifestyle before investing. And if you still cannot choose, why not pick and choose a customized collection across both lines?
Adding a few specialized pieces from each into your arsenal lets these two premium brands complement rather than compete for space in your kitchen!
Related Articles:
